83rd Academy Awards – Choices, Choices, Choices
What do you mean I’m just like all the others? I’m unique! I’m a beautiful snowflake!
Here’s what it all comes down to. Here’s where all the hard work, press tours and hour after hour of standing around on set while the lighting guys get exactly the right shadows to fall across the wall in background. This is the stage that everyone in the industry wants to walk across holding a tiny statue that never fails to surprise the new owner by how heavy it really is. To those people out there who say “Pish Posh” or “The Oscars are all politics and mainstream hype, I don’t need one.”, well, you’re lying. This year there are some categories which feel somewhat locked, a true front-runner eclipsing the poor remaining nominees in the glorious shadow of critical acclaim, but there are many still up in the air and the ceremony still promises to cause many baited breaths, sweaty fists and screams of joy and pain (and that’s just for the people in my Oscar pool). So before the sun sets on that fateful night, I will offer a few choice thoughts on the nominations this year: (I will mark the ones I have not seen with “*”)
Best Picture:
- Black Swan
- The Fighter
- Inception
- The Kids Are All Right *
- The King’s Speech
- 127 Hours *
- The Social Network
- Toy Story 3
- True Grit
- Winter’s Bone *
Originally I was a big fan of opening the Best Picture field up to 10 films and I would say at this moment in time I am still a fan, but maybe not as strong as before. Let’s be honest, the major push for opening the field was The Dark Knight being overlooked, but what it really did was open people’s eyes to the fact that the Academy needs to follow in the shoes of the Hollywood Foreign Press and create Best Drama and Best Comedy/Musical, but that’s for a much longer conversation. As to this year’s crop of fine films, the two heavyweights battling in the center of the ring are The King’s Speech and The Social Network. While many will claim The King’s Speech is much more attuned to the Oscar voting crowd (which they would absolutely correct in thinking), The Social Network was a tremendous achievement in making something extraordinary out of what most people previously wrote off as “that movie coming out about Facebook”. Fincher and Sorkin created a devastating and scathing pair behind the screen and it is that sheer power and talent which could very well push The Social Network across the big stage that night. Personally, I loved both films and I don’t care which one wins, but if I was a betting man, I would give the slight edge to The Social Network.
Best Director:
- Darren Aronofsky for Black Swan
- David O’Russell for The Fighter
- Tom Hooper for The King’s Speech
- David Fincher for The Social Network
- Joel Coen and Ethan Coen for True Grit
I was honestly not the biggest fan of True Grit. I found it to be a really well done film, but not to the tune of twelve Academy nominations. No Country for Old Men was far superior and the Coen brothers have possibly in my eyes become a victim to their own talent in previous works. All of these movies did feature amazing performances and I always give that credit equally to the actor and the director, because the director is truly the one to pull those performances forward. I think this could honestly be the free-for-all battle of the night, even a dark horse shot for the Coen brothers. I wouldn’t be really mad either way it went (maybe if the Coen’s got it I would be slightly miffed). If I need to cast a vote one way or the other, I am going to go back to Fincher and The Social Network.
Best Actor in a Leading Role:
- Javier Bardem in Biutiful *
- Jeff Bridges in True Grit
- Jesse Eisenberg in The Social Network
- Colin Firth in The King’s Speech
- James Franco in 127 Hours *
This is where The Social Network will lose its steam. In the acting realm, although still quite good, The Social Network gets beaten in each round. Colin Firth is the clear leader in this category and for very good reason. The man is the consummate technician and makes everything look simple, clean and honest (and as Jon Stewart points out, “can really wear a sweater.”) Much praise has been handed out to Franco and Bridges, while extremely strong and glowing remarks from people like Julia Roberts have surrounded the performance of Bardem, but the statue will likely be going home with the King of Britain that night.
Best Actress in a Leading Role:
- Annette Bening in The Kids Are All Right *
- Nicole Kidman in Rabbit Hole *
- Jennifer Lawrence in Winter’s Bone *
- Natalie Portman in Black Swan
- Michelle Williams in Blue Valentine *
While I have heard many wonderful things about all of these performances and not actually witnessed any of the others myself, Portman will undoubtedly climb the stage with grace, humility and probably a good deal of care, since she is incredibly pregnant. The swan princess will bathe in the light of what her character strove for in the film, perfection.
Best Actor in a Supporting Role:
- Christian Bale in The Fighter
- John Hawkes in Winter’s Bone *
- Jeremy Renner in The Town *
- Mark Ruffalo in The Kids Are All Right *
- Geoffrey Rush in The King’s Speech
Once again going above and beyond pure emotional transformation, Bale put his body in harm’s way and mutated into the stringy, wiry crack addicted former boxing hopeful, Dicky Eklund. Rush was also quite excellent as the comic foil to Firth’s stammering rage, but I imagine we will not be seeing him share the stage with his regal co-star. Bale will deliver the knockout blow (hopefully, not for real).
Best Actress in a Supporting Role:
- Amy Adams in The Fighter
- Helena Bonham Carter in The King’s Speech
- Melissa Leo in The Fighter
- Hailee Steinfeld in True Grit
- Jacki Weaver in Animal Kingdom
How could I avoid calling this anything but apt when you have two amazing performances by two amazing women battling it out inside a film called The Fighter. Hell, it practically writes itself. Steinfeld gave a good shot, but she’s young and has a great career ahead of her and I have no doubt we will see her name on this list again. Yet, back in the ring, Leo has been taking the kudos so far and while Adams was surprisingly raw, I believe Leo will continue her reign as champion of this category.
Best Animated Feature:
- How to Train Your Dragon
- The Illusionist *
- Toy Story 3
Right now my main issue here is that Toy Story 3 is listed in both Best Animated Feature and the Best Picture category and I thought you had to choose which one you wanted to be eligible for. Even though they have no shot at Best Picture this year, I find it a little unfair if the film were to take the top spot and then still claim Best Animated Feature as well. Seems like a touch of overkill. Yet, beyond that pettiness on my part, I enjoyed Toy Story 3 a lot, but it didn’t actually move me to the extent of many of my cinema-addicted brethren. I would like to see it go to How to Train Your Dragon, which actually just swept through the animation awards as well. Still holding great love for Pixar, but I have to give it to the other guys this year.
Best Art Direction:
- Alice in Wonderland
- Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1
- Inception
- The King’s Speech
- True Grit
Once again, I kinda fell off the majority bandwagon this year in the praise for Potter Part 1. I am eagerly anticipating part two, partially because I know the big fight that is coming for our well-loved and well-worn characters, but also because I am hoping it will be better than the first half. As for this year, I’m a little torn between Inception and Alice in Wonderland, but I will have to toss my vote in with the more colorful and boisterous Tim Burton, the director of Alice (words that are rarely used to describe him).
Best Cinematography:
- Black Swan
- Inception
- The King’s Speech
- The Social Network
- True Grit
This comes down to the battle of characters with fractured minds and how well that was imagined and displayed out to us. Black Swan and Inception are my two favorites in this category. Beyond the similarities in the main characters, what we also have is a battle of the go-to cinematographers. Darren Aronofsky, director of Black Swan, went to his trusty friend Matthew Libatique, who also created the amazing visuals for Requiem for a Dream and The Fountain, while the director of Inception, Christopher Nolan, pulled in his top gun, Wally Pfister, who brought us the amazing sights of Batman Begins, The Dark Knight and even Nolan’s big breakout Memento. Tough choice here…slight edge…Inception.
Best Costume Design:
- Alice in Wonderland
- I Am Love *
- The King’s Speech
- The Tempest *
- True Grit
The most outwardly obvious choice is Alice in Wonderland, due to the flamboyant and fantastical nature of the setting, but you can never see the silent killer coming from the subtle dressings of WWII England (The King’s Speech) or the roughness of the wild west (True Grit). I’ll stick with Alice, but I’m quite prepared to be wrong here.
Best Documentary Feature:
- Exit Through the Gift Shop
- Gasland *
- Inside Job *
- Restrepo *
- Waste Land *
Having only seen one of these at the moment, it’s obviously hard for me to really vote. On top of that, the one that I did see, Exit Through the Gift Shop, is widely debated as to whether it is even really a documentary or a piece of street art in itself, created by the mysterious Banksy. If that rumor is true, i don’t think it should be allowed to be in this category, but by answering the question it also loses all the power behind the film. Catch-22, there you have it. Words on the wind though put this between Exit Through the Gift Shop and Gasland.
Best Documentary Short Subject:
- Killing in the Name *
- Poster Girl *
- Strangers No More *
- Sun Come Up *
- The Warriors of Qiugang *
I am going to try to find a way to see any of these because every year I feel bad for not even making the effort after the filmmakers have obviously done such a good job in creating these pieces. Plus, one of them mentions “warriors” and I am hoping for some real life Kung-Fu stuff.
Best Film Editing:
- Black Swan
- The Fighter
- The King’s Speech
- 127 Hours *
- The Social Network
I am going to run with Black Swan here because I felt that the editing here was incredibly important to giving the story its power and persuasion. Badly cut together we would never have followed the fragile ballerina into her fractured world. The editing mirrored her mindset and created the perfect environment for the character to morph and change along the way.
Best Foreign Film:
- Biutiful (from Mexico) *
- Dogtooth (from Greece) *
- In a Better World (from Denmark) *
- Incendies (from Canada) *
- Outside the Law (aka: Hors-la-loi from Algeria) *
Yep, not a good sense of anything here either except for Javier Bardem’s supposed masterpiece of a performance in Biutiful. Dogtooth has also gotten a lot of buzz around the indie houses, but it really hasn’t given me a sense of overpowering Bardem, who might end up the one man show this year.
Best Original Score:
- How to Train Your Dragon
- Inception
- The King’s Speech
- 127 Hours *
- The Social Network
OK, I give credit to Hanz Zimmer and his illustrious career in musical scores, but that damn tone from the Inception score just was played over and over and eventually played out. I found the Inception score to be overtly heavy and overbearing, at times, not all the way through. While three of the others are all well known names in the field, I think this year will go to the new kid on the scoring block, Trent Reznor and Atticus Rose for their work on The Social Network. It was subtle and discreet, but intensely valuable to the overall mood of the film.
Best Makeup:
- Barney’s Vision
- The Way Back
- The Wolfman
Here’s where you start to find those movies that no one saw or very few liked, but had something special going on that the audiences might have missed while thinking, “This is a terrible film.” So, in that mindset, congrats to The Wolfman for scoring the nomination. Yet, since I have only seen one of these at the moment, I can only say that the wear and tear created on the weary travelers of The Way Back was truly exceptional and would make a deserving trophy winner that night.
Best Original Song:
- “Coming Home” from Country Strong *
- “I See the Light” from Tangled *
- “If I Rise” from 127 Hours *
- “We Belong Together” from Toy Story 3
Glad we have the yearly toss to Randy Newman (he would be the Toy Story 3 nomination). The man could write a song about an ant basking in a misty ray of sunlight next to a puddle on the sidewalk and it would still delight the voters throughout the Academy (and honestly, I might hum along to it as well). A.R. Rahman was the big music maker of last year with the music from Slumdog Millionaire, which might give him some buzz this time around, but I think everyone, whether they admit it or not, is deep down a country fan and that’s why my money falls under the dulcet tones of “Coming Home”.
Best Animated Short Film:
- Day & Night
- The Gruffalo *
- Let’s Pollute *
- The Lost Thing *
- Madagascar, a Journey Diary (Madagascar, carnet de voyage) *
Admittedly I have only seen one of these, but the one I saw was made by Pixar (Day & Night), so really, that’s all you need. Plus, as usual, it was incredibly well thought out, executed and overall brought pure enjoyment to everyone in the theater.
Best Live Action Short Film:
- The Confession *
- The Crush *
- God of Love *
- Na Wewe *
- Wish 143 *
If The Crush from the list above was actually just the trailer from the Alicia Silverstone movie from the early 90′s, I would pick that by a mile, but since I highly doubt that is the case, this is a complete crap shoot for me. I’m going to put my mark on Na Wewe, just because the title gives me absolutely nothing to go on. Mystery makes it intriguing.
Best Sound Editing:
- Inception
- Toy Story 3
- Tron: Legacy
- True Grit
- Unstoppable *
Yes, that’s right, it can now officially be called “Academy Award Nominated – Tron: Legacy“. Nerds around the world, please continue rejoicing at your leisure (or between episodes of The IT Crowd). I actually believe Tron might have a shot here, right next to Inception. Those two really did have a beautifully intricate and expansive soundscape, which without those the movies would certainly fall many, many notches down the totem pole. I’m leaning towards Inception, but the geek in me hopes Tron pulls through.
Best Sound Mixing:
- Inception
- The King’s Speech
- Salt
- The Social Network
- True Grit
Following nicely on the heels of my last commentary, I slightly shudder at the idea of “Academy Award Nominated – Salt“. Never saw that coming in a million years. Inception will likely take this jewel home.
Best Visual Effects:
- Alice in Wonderland
- Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1
- Hereafter *
- Inception
- Iron Man 2
There was noting more exciting about the effects in Iron Man 2 over the original Iron Man, so I feel it kind of cancels itself out. Hereafter is too awkwardly mild in scope to break through the intensity of the rest of the crowd. As for Potter, well, I kind of find a movie mostly about kids in a tent a little light on visual effects. Once again Inception finds itself battling for supremacy against a strong opponent, once again the incredibly imaginative Burton and crew. In Alice the effects were actually the thing that impressed me most coming out of the film, the world, the characters mis-sized heads, everything down to the acid-trip induced minutiae. I think Alice deserves it, but Inception will likely take it.
Best Adapted Screenplay:
- 127 Hours *
- The Social Network
- Toy Story 3
- True Grit
- Winter’s Bone *
Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin. Aaron Sorkin.
Nuff said. (he wrote The Social Network)
Best Original Screenplay:
- Another Year *
- The Fighter
- Inception
- The Kids Are All Right *
- The King’s Speech
My feelings are torn between The King’s Speech, which was terribly beautiful, subtle and moving, and The Fighter, which surprised and enthralled me with its raw energy and depth. If either one wins, I am happy. Otherwise, sad, sad me.
There you have it. As you can see, my beliefs on who should win are heavily dependent on whether or not I got a chance to even see the film, which is really how it should be. I look forward to hearing your thoughts on who you hope for or just who you think will win.

